Need Legal Help? Call 215.925.4451

Pennsylvania Emergency Room & Hospital Medical Malpractice Law Update: The Danger of HB 2299

Phil Blackman-Pennsylvania New Jersey Personal Injury LawyerPublished on behalf of Philip Blackman, an experienced personal injury lawyer who has devoted his entire career to helping individuals and families who have been injured due to medical malpractice, car accidents, fall accidents and more. FREE Consultations: 215.925.4451

The Pennsylvania House of Representatives is currently considering HB 2299, a bill which would make it harder for medical negligence victims in Pennsylvania to sue responsible parties.

This bill was introduced by Rep Cutler (R. Lancaster County, 100th District) last month, after lobbying efforts of Milliron Associates. The Pennsylvania House of Representatives will conduct a hearing on the bill this summer.

The problem with this bill is that it would change the negligence standard applied in cases of emergency room hospital negligence. If passed, emergency room personnel would only be liable in situations where there was gross negligence. It would also change the burden of proof from preponderance of the evidence to clear and convincing. In other words, the plaintiff/victim would have to prove gross negligence with clear and convincing evidence, which is a much higher burden than the current burden of proof-preponderance of the evidence.

The danger of this bill, if passed, is that it marginalizes a population that already faces socioeconomic hardships. Minorities and the poor seek emergency room care as the first and oftentimes only source of medical treatment. This is generally because they cannot afford health insurance. In addition, minorities often receive lower quality care and higher wait times in emergency rooms. Passage of this bill would essentially compound these issues.

According to Milliron Associates’ May 25, 2012 “Legislative Update:”

“Milliron Associates, on the behalf of Pennsylvania Chapter, American College of Emergency Physicians (PEP), lobbied to have H.B. 2299 introduced. H.B. 2299 changes the standard of proof for emergency physicians and personnel from “Preponderance of the Evidence” to “clear and convincing” evidence (i.e. a higher proof making it more difficult for an award in a lawsuit). H.B. 2299 was introduced on May 9th and the House will hold a hearing on this topic over the summer months. “

This statement fails to mention that the crux of the bill would change the level of negligence which must be shown in emergency room malpractice cases in Pennsylvania. Again, if passed, the bill would change the standard which applies to emergency room medical negligence cases in Pennsylvania from ordinary negligence to gross negligence. Doing so is a great danger to the thousands of Pennsylvania residents who receive medical treatment at emergency rooms.

Related Legal Articles:

If you’d like to have your case reviewed by our Philadelphia, Pennsylvania emergency room malpractice lawyers, call 215.925.4451 for a free, no obligation legal consultation.

The medical malpractice lawyers at Schwartz & Blackman handle cases in the Pennsylvania and New Jersey area:

  • PA: Berks County, Bucks County, Chester County, Delaware County, Montgomery County, Philadelphia County, Allentown, Lehigh Valley, Norristown, Philadelphia
  • NJ: Atlantic County, Burlington County, Camden County, Gloucester County, Mercer County, Middlesex County, Monmouth County, Camden, Cherry Hill, New Jersey shore cities

*This website does not provide legal advice. Every case is unique and it is important to get a qualified, expert legal opinion prior to making any decisions about your case.  See the full disclaimer at the bottom of this page.

Published: June 26, 2012

Medical malpractice Law Library

Philadelphia Emergency Room Mistakes – Too Common and Not Always Revealed

Medical malpractice in emergency rooms, hospitals, and doctors' offices happens every day. No one is perfect. Everyone makes mistakes. A great piece of advice for young lawyers who are just starting out - it's a given that you're going to make mistakes; it's what you...

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Hospital Emergency Room Malpractice Law – The Statute of Limitations

In cases of hospital and emergency room malpractice, Pennsylvania's statute of limitations is two years from the date of the injury. However, in cases where the patient was unable to discover the abuse, the statute of limitations may be tolled. In such a situation,...

Common Emergency Room Mistakes in a Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Lawsuit

Emergency room errors are very common and often result in death or worsened outcomes. The main reason emergency room errors are common is the nature of the emergency room, a high volume, fast-paced environment, coupled with lack of training, inadequate staffing, etc....

8 Tips for Better Treatment in a Hospital Emergency Room or Clinic

Over the past several years, emergency room waiting times have gotten longer for multiple reasons such as increased costs of health care,  hospital closures, etc. Historically, people with low income and minorities have poorer outcomes and longer wait times during...

Pharmacy Errors in a Pennsylvania Hospital Medical Malpractice Case

Pharmacy errors are often deadly, and most victims of pharmacy error or their families will never discover the error. This is due in large part to the fact that underlying diseases and illnesses are often believed to be the cause of symptoms or death. The reality is...



    *No attorney-client relationship is created by use of this email form. Do not email confidential or time-sensitive information. Call the firm for immediate assistance.


    Pennsylvania Office
    The Pavilion
    261 Old York Rd., Suite 504
    Jenkintown, PA 19046
    Tel: (215) 925-4451
    Fax: (215) 574-1200

    New Jersey Office
    1415 Route 70 East
    Cherry Hill, NJ 08034
    Tel: (856) 427-0614
    Fax: (856) 424-3690