Need Legal Help? Call 215.925.4451

Legal Causation in a Pennsylvania Motorcycle Accident Head Injury Case

Phil Blackman-Pennsylvania New Jersey Personal Injury LawyerPublished on behalf of Philip Blackman, an experienced personal injury lawyer who has devoted his entire career to helping individuals and families who have been injured due to medical malpractice, car accidents, fall accidents and more. FREE Consultations: 215.925.4451

In motorcycle accident cases where the rider was not wearing a helmet, defendants often argue that it wasn’t the accident which caused the head or brain injuries or damages, but rather it was the rider’s own actions which led to the injuries or damages.

In order to prevail in a motorcycle accident case in Pennsylvania, a rider must be able to prove that the defendant’s negligence caused the accident, and the defendant’s negligence caused the injuries.

In head injury motorcycle accident cases, there are two main defenses: 1. the rider’s own negligence led to the accident and 2. the rider’s failure to wear a helmet caused the head injury, not the accident.

In these kinds of cases, defendants often argue that the rider’s own negligent action caused the injury. For example, in an intersection accident case, defendants might argue that the rider was speeding or had an opportunity to avoid the accident, but failed to so do.

In addition, defendants will attempt to defend a head injury case by blaming the head injury on the rider’s failure to use a helmet. This kind of defense is often raised by the driver who caused the accident or by the product manufacturer in a products liability case. Defendants often allege that the rider contributed to the injury by failing to wear a helmet.

However, this defense is hardly ever accepted and most defendants will never be permitted to make the argument in court. So long as the rider meets the requirements under Pennsylvania’s helmet law and was not legally required to wear a helmet at the time of the accident, the defendant will not be permitted to argue that the failure to wear the helmet was the actual cause of the head injury.

Related Legal Articles:

For more information, contact our Pennsylvania and New Jersey motorcycle accident lawyers at 215.925.4451. Our lawyers are available for a free, no obligation legal consultation.

The lawyers at Schwartz & Blackman handle motorcycle accident cases in the Pennsylvania and New Jersey area:

  • PA: Berks County, Bucks County, Chester County, Delaware County, Montgomery County, Philadelphia County, Allentown, Lehigh Valley, Norristown, Philadelphia
  • NJ: Atlantic County, Burlington County, Camden County, Gloucester County, Mercer County, Middlesex County, Monmouth County, Camden, Cherry Hill, New Jersey shore cities

*This website does not provide legal advice. Every case is unique and it is important to get a qualified, expert legal opinion prior to making any decisions about your case. See the full disclaimer at the bottom of this page.

Published: July 17, 2012

Motorcycle Accident Law Library

Is Your Pennsylvania Car Accident Case Worth Pursuing?

Pursuing a car accident case in Pennsylvania depends on the factual and legal issues which vary from case to case. Most of the time, deciding whether to pursue a car accident case depends on the likelihood of a successful outcome. For some, a successful outcome may be...

Injury & Medical Treatment in PA Car, Motorcycle & Truck Accident Cases

Most personal injury/accident cases boil down to two issues: 1. strength of liability and 2. the nature and extent of the physical injuries. In many car, motorcycle and truck accident cases in Pennsylvania, fault will be clear. The other driver may have run a red...

Determining Value in Serious Car, Motorcycle or Truck Accident Cases in Pennsylvania

Determining value in a car, motorcycle or truck accident case does not happen overnight. It takes months to develop the facts of the case, especially the damages. When serious injuries result, medical treatment is often ongoing and determining whether an injury is...

PA Car & Motorcycle Accident Law -What is a Loss of Consortium Claim?

Under tort law in Pennsylvania, a spouse has a separate right to recover in an accident lawsuit such as a car or motorcycle accident case. Known as a "loss of consortium claim," this type of legal claim is based upon the harm to the relationship between the injured...

Texting and Drunk Driving – A Rising & Very Serious Problem

Over the past few years, texting and driving accidents have made major headlines all across the country. However, in the past year, we are seeing more and more cases of drunk drivers who text or otherwise use their phones. The risk of causing an accident when driving...



    *No attorney-client relationship is created by use of this email form. Do not email confidential or time-sensitive information. Call the firm for immediate assistance.


    Pennsylvania Office
    The Pavilion
    261 Old York Rd., Suite 504
    Jenkintown, PA 19046
    Tel: (215) 925-4451
    Fax: (215) 574-1200

    New Jersey Office
    1415 Route 70 East
    Cherry Hill, NJ 08034
    Tel: (856) 427-0614
    Fax: (856) 424-3690