Need Legal Help? Call 215.925.4451

HB 2299 Would Harm Pennsylvania’s Most Vulnerable Citizens

Phil Blackman-Pennsylvania New Jersey Personal Injury LawyerPublished on behalf of Philip Blackman, an experienced personal injury lawyer who has devoted his entire career to helping individuals and families who have been injured due to medical malpractice, car accidents, fall accidents and more. FREE Consultations: 215.925.4451

Right now, House Bill 2299 is being considered in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives. If passed, it would change the rights of people who receive substandard medical care in hospital emergency rooms or clinics in Pennsylvania.

One of the reasons cited for passage of this bill is that since passage of the EMTALA, Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act 42, Pennsylvania area hospitals must provide treatment to ER patients, regardless of the patient’s ability to pay. In other words, because federal mandates now require that hospitals treat those who have no insurance, hospitals want the right to treat them with substandard medical care.

This law would shield emergency rooms from malpractice suits absent “gross negligence,” which is a difficult standard to meet, far more difficult than the current standard of ordinary negligence. Shielding hospital emergency room personnel from liability is especially problematic because minorities already receive longer wait times and delays in the emergency room. A law like HB2299 would only make that worse.

The solution is not changing medical negligence laws in Pennsylvania to make it harder for those injured by negligence in a hospital ER from suing those responsible. Rather, the solution is making sure that patients can afford medical insurance.

Professionals, be they doctors, lawyers, judges should never be excused from ordinary negligence. It is a matter of principle. Regardless of whether a person can pay or not, the treatment, medical, legal or otherwise, should be the same.

Voice your opinion. Contact your local state representative. For a list of all Pennsylvania House of Representative members, please visit

Related Legal Articles:

Contact Schwartz & Blackman at 215.925.4451.

*This website does not provide legal advice. Every case is unique and it is important to get a qualified, expert legal opinion prior to making any decisions about your case. See the full disclaimer at the bottom of this page.

Published: June 26, 2012

Medical malpractice Law Library

Philadelphia Emergency Room Mistakes – Too Common and Not Always Revealed

Medical malpractice in emergency rooms, hospitals, and doctors' offices happens every day. No one is perfect. Everyone makes mistakes. A great piece of advice for young lawyers who are just starting out - it's a given that you're going to make mistakes; it's what you...

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Hospital Emergency Room Malpractice Law – The Statute of Limitations

In cases of hospital and emergency room malpractice, Pennsylvania's statute of limitations is two years from the date of the injury. However, in cases where the patient was unable to discover the abuse, the statute of limitations may be tolled. In such a situation,...

Pennsylvania Hospital Medical Malpractice Law – Theories of Negligence Against Hospitals

Hospital negligence is an unfortunate reality. Every day, thousands of patients trust the care and treatment they receive at a hospital. However, many of those patients will suffer hospital malpractice which results in severe harm or even death. The laws of...

8 Tips for Better Treatment in a Hospital Emergency Room or Clinic

Over the past several years, emergency room waiting times have gotten longer for multiple reasons such as increased costs of health care,  hospital closures, etc. Historically, people with low income and minorities have poorer outcomes and longer wait times during...

Proving Emergency Room Mistake & Medical Malpractice in Pennsylvania

Emergency room mistakes are common, especially considering that there are approximately 120 million visits to the emergency room per year. Emergency room personnel and doctors must make quick decisions, usually based on incomplete data in a high demand and oftentimes,...



    *No attorney-client relationship is created by use of this email form. Do not email confidential or time-sensitive information. Call the firm for immediate assistance.


    Pennsylvania Office
    The Pavilion
    261 Old York Rd., Suite 504
    Jenkintown, PA 19046
    Tel: (215) 925-4451
    Fax: (215) 574-1200

    New Jersey Office
    1415 Route 70 East
    Cherry Hill, NJ 08034
    Tel: (856) 427-0614
    Fax: (856) 424-3690